Dine in · Pickup · Delivery within 4 miles · $3 delivery fee · $15 minimum Order now

Crispino’s storefront on Higbie Lane at night

About Crispino's Pizza in West Islip

Crispino’s Pizzeria storefront at 159 Higbie Lane

About Crispino's Pizza

Crispino’s Pizza is a pizza restaurant at 159 Higbie Ln in West Islip, NY. You’ll find us near Twin Harbor Smiles and Arbore Bros Pools & Spas. Come in for lunch and dinner any day of the week.

The heart of the menu is the pizza pies section: nine choices, from the 18 Lg Pizza to the 14 Small Pizza. There’s also a pizza by the slice list with five choices. The 12 Cauliflower Pie ($15.95) is made with can be made Gluten Free-Just Ask! The White Pie ($29.95) is made with lot’s of Ricotta, Hint of Garlic, Topped with Mozzarella & Romano Cheeses. For guests who avoid gluten, the menu has the 12 Gluten Free Pie and the 12 Cauliflower Pie.

Guests rate Crispino’s Pizza 4.5 stars across 413+ Google reviews. “The baked ziti was baked the perfect amount and added some fried chicken which had a tasty breading that was not falling apart or chewy, it was delicious!” (Moni, Google review).

You can eat in, take out or order delivery. You can order ahead online and pick it up at the restaurant. We deliver within about 4 miles for a $3 fee with a $15 minimum. There’s a free parking lot and free street parking. Stop by 159 Higbie Ln, or call (631) 893-8000 and we’ll have your order ready.

Come see us at 159 Higbie Ln, browse the menu.

See the menu